Risepoint Faculty Center
African American female student studying remotely from home, using a laptop.
Assessment and grading Job aid

Design to assess student process

  |  3 min read

Given advancements in AI, a final paper or presentation can show what a student submitted without showing what they learned. You can add a few purposeful checkpoints to an existing assessment to make student process visible without having to significantly increase workloads.

Choose evidence that matches the outcome

Start with a skill students must demonstrate. Then ask: what evidence would students need to produce to demonstrate that they have learned that skill? For evaluating content, that might mean selecting a credible source, noticing a limitation, or weighing conflicting claims. For problem-solving, it might mean explaining why one approach is more defensible than another.

Make the process visible

There are several opportunities across the scope of an assessment where adding a process check could be valuable: before work begins (plan), during the initial work stage (progress), during finalization (revise), and after the submission of the final product (justify). Each of these invites slightly different checkpoints and surfaces different aspects of student process.

Use the framework below to select the stage(s) that fit your learning outcome, decide what to collect, and determine what it can reveal:

StageAsk the student to submitWhat you can learn
1. PlanA research proposal, outline, project plan, etc.See what the student intends to do.
2. ProgressAn annotated source, draft claim, worked example, early interpretation, etc.See how the student works through the assessment and show gaps while there is still time to respond.
3. ReviseAn explanation of a revision, judgment of the validity of a critique, a response to a comment, etc.See how the student judges and applies feedback.
4. JustifyAn explanation of what underpins the final product, a walk-through of the solution, details about why a choice was made, etc.See the rationale behind the final product.

Adapt the evidence to your course. A nursing student might revise an initial prioritization after receiving new patient information. A business student might compare interpretations of a dataset before making a recommendation.


Apply the framework to translate a comment into action

Learning outcome: Use feedback to make a substantive revision.

Student instructions

“Choose one piece of feedback on your draft. Name the rubric criterion it relates to. Revise the relevant passage. Submit the original and revised versions with a short note explaining what you understood the feedback to mean, what you changed, and why. If you chose not to follow it, explain your reasoning and next step.”

Evidence of learning

Whether students can interpret feedback, connect it to a criterion, make a purposeful change, and recognize when feedback needs clarification. Feedback supports learning when students interpret and use it.

Optional AI variation: If AI use is allowed, students can compare AI suggestions with peer or instructor feedback and note what they accepted, adapted, or rejected. This makes their evaluation of feedback sources visible; it does not establish who authored the work.


Keep these considerations in mind

  • Be purposeful. Align process evidence with learning goals and use only purposeful checkpoints. A checkpoint should help you identify student thinking or respond to it.
  • Grade the learning. Assess evidence selection, reasoning, revision choices, or another skill named in the outcome, rather than focusing on polish or volume.
  • Keep checkpoints manageable. Be careful about workloads. A plan may be completion-based; a draft may receive brief feedback; the final work can carry most of the grade.
  • Be transparent. Students may not be used to process evaluation. Tell students why you’re asking for each checkpoint and how it will be used.
  • Design for access. Use clear directions and flexible ways to submit process work. Avoid timed oral or handwritten requirements unless they are essential to the outcome; some restrictive formats can disadvantage students who use assistive technology or need accommodations.

Use this checklist for a quick redesign

  1. Name the learning outcome you want to see.
  2. Choose one or two decisions students make along the way.
  3. Add a short checkpoint that makes those decisions visible.
  4. Decide whether each item is graded, reviewed, and/or used for feedback.
  5. After the assignment, keep only the steps that helped you respond to learning.